Pakistan’s ISI – The Burqa comes off
Jul 27th
The latest from Matt’s Meditations – By Matt Holzmann
Wikileaks has just released thousands of pages of classified U.S. and ISAF intelligence documents outlining the fundamental issues of the Afghan campaign; the incompetence, duplicity and corruption of the Afghan government and the pervasive involvement of Pakistan’s ISI in supporting, tasking, and directing Taliban activities within Afghanistan. This documentation represents a massive security breach, but confirms numerous data points developed by other sources in recent weeks.
These documents combined with the recent report by the London School of Economics Crisis States Research Centre entitled The Sun in the Sky: The Relationship between Pakistan’s ISI and Afghan Insurgents provide an incredibly detailed picture of the support and logistics provided by Pakistan’s Inter Services Agency, their equivalent of the CIA, to the Afghan Taliban. It rips away any pretense that Pakistan is an ally in the Afghan war.
Pakistan has two foreign policy platforms that are inimical to Western interests. The first regards India. They find India and its predominant Hindu faith abhorrent. The second is Afghanistan, or a bit more precisely, the concept of Pashtunistan. After partition, the state of Pakistan was split into East (Bengal) and West Pakistan, 1,000 miles apart with India in the middle. East Pakistan had little in common with the West, economically, linguistically, or culturally, and in fact had better relations with India. The only common thread was a shared Islamic heritage. In 1970, the Pakistani Army killed between 300,000 and 3 Million Bengalis in what was described as an extended massacre. The root cause was raw power. Bengal revolted and after 9 months won its independence. Pakistan’s already shaky self image took a major blow.
The major flash point since then has been Kashmir, where the Indian and Pakistani Armies regularly trade artillery salvos and Islamic violence is common. The ISI are the primary sponsors of the Harkat – ul – Mujahadeen and other terrorist groups focusing on Kashmir. They use these fighters as proxies in a continuing low-level war which includes the 2008 Mumbai terrorist assault in which 178 people were killed. Just 10 days ago, and number of pro-Islamic protesters were killed.
In the west of Pakistan, the central government also contends with the tribal areas. The Durand Line was established by the British Raj in 1893 as an artificial border between Pakistan and Afghanistan, dividing the Pashtun people in the south between both countries. The Pashtun have always been independent and are the largest ethnic group in Afghanistan. In Pakistan, the Pashtun are the largest ethnic group along the Northwest frontier,and are a buffer against Afghanistan. Maintaining that buffer and countering both a strong Afghan government and Indian influence in that country drives Pakistani policy. The ISI is acting in the interests of the elected government, according to the LSE report, and in doing so is the primary facilitator for both the Taliban and the Haqqani Network.
The LSE report is the result of hundreds of interviews of Taliban commanders, former members of the Taliban government, Afghan elders, foreign diplomats, and current Afghan government officials. Because the ISI is a secret organization, there is little verifiable data from that source. However, now 91,000 individual reports by US and allied line units, individual sources, “information centers”, outside contractors operating inside of Pakistan, and other sources are painting a much more detailed picture of direct Pakistani involvement.
The Quetta Shura, the high council of the Afghan Taliban, meet 10-12 times per year somewhere in or around the city of Quetta in Pakistan’s Northwest Frontier. One LSE interview subject stated that between three and seven ISI officials attend each meeting, and that the ISI is responsible for the meeting logistics and location. The ISI is reported to exploit tribal and political fissures within the Taliban to its benefit, which is consistent with the national policy objectives of Pakistan. The ISI holds power through its financial support, access to weapons and materiel, and sanctuary for Taliban officials. Most of the weaponry, including and especially explosives for IED’s used against Western forces in Afghanistan, are delivered to the Taliban by the ISI. Pakistani agents work hand in hand with the military to facilitate delivery of weapons and ammunition to Afghan Taliban at the border. This is done in order to ensure that those weapons are not turned on the Pakistani military in that country’s current insurgency.
Some of the reports indicate ISI mission planning, including some of the most heinous car bombings and the suicide bombing that damaged the main highway bridge into Kandahar several months ago. ISI agents and either active duty or former Pakistani military are also said to plan and lead specific missions within Afghanistan.
The ISI also enforces its authority through selective detention of senior Taliban leaders according to the report. The arrests of 7 Taliban leaders in February were intended as a warning that the ISI will have a major role, if not primacy, in any negotiations over Afghanistan. The report also states that a large number of Taliban are fighting under duress from the ISI. It states that the ISI is directly involved in the most controversial attacks, including the assassinations of tribal elders and attacks on schools, bridges and other key targets.To enforce discipline, it is said the ISI will assassinate those who do not cooperate.
Several interviews suggested that the Taliban are highly resentful of the ISI, one leader saying that the only people hated more than the Americans were the ISI. One political leader said that “everything is controlled by the ISI. Without the agreement of the ISI, the insurgency would be impossible”. A joint U.S., NATO and Afghan report in 2006 concluded that the ISI not only provided vital sanctuary for the Taliban and Haqqani Network, but also paid them and pressured them to fight. A Taliban commander in Southern Afghanistan said that they are paid a bounty of $4,000 – $5,000 per ISAF soldier killed. He said many Afghans believe the United States is funding the insurgency with their support of Pakistan.
Between 2002 – 2010, Pakistan has received $18 Billion in aid from the United States government. In February, President Obama requested another $3 Billion. Hillary Clinton just promised another $7.5 Billion 10 days ago, and to facilitate the import of mangoes from Pakistan to help bolster America’s image there.
At the same time, most of the material for the allies prosecution of the war from gasoline to ammunition to armored vehicles passes through Karachi on its way to Afghanistan. Much of this is subject to hijacking and attacks within Pakistan. Just a few weeks ago, 50+ tractor trailers carrying war materiel were destroyed near Islamabad, where they were thought to be safer than nearer the border.
As one of the most corrupt countries in the world, it seems the Pakistani government and it’s component individuals are making money coming and going while supporting jihad as best they can. There is a massive Saudi Wahabbist influence to complement Pakistani Deobandism through the madrassas and direct funding of the Taliban, estimated to be close to $900 million since 2001. The ISI know exactly where Mullah Omar, Sirajuddin Haqqani, and most likely, Osama Bin Laden are at any given time. Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the 9/11 mastermind was arrested only after strong pressure was exerted by the United States. Not much happens in Pakistan that the ISI doesn’t know about or that they are not directly involved in.
Afghanistan produces 90% of the world’s heroin base. Most of that moves through Pakistan. In the great jihad, exporting narcotics is simply war by other means.
Pakistan is one of the bases of global jihad. At least most Afghans want peace. They know the price of war. It is for our leaders to determine policy, but it has become ever more clear that Pakistan is a part of the problem, not the solution.
I’m a JournoLister – Repeat after me:
Jul 26th
The latest on jounoList from the Daily Caller.
“On the question of liberals coordinating, what the hell’s wrong with some critical mass of liberal bloggers & journalists saying the following among themselves:
“McCain lies about his maverick status. Routinely, cavalierly, cynically. Palin lies about her maverick status. Ditto, ditto, ditto. McCain has a wretched temperament. McCain is a warmonger. Palin belongs to a crackpot church and feels warmly about a crackpot party that trashes America.
“Repeat after me:
“McCain lies about his maverick status. Routinely, cavalierly, cynically. Palin lies about her maverick status. Ditto, ditto, ditto. McCain has a wretched temperament. McCain is a warmonger. Palin belongs to a crackpot church and feels warmly about a crackpot party that trashes America.
“These people are cynical. These people are taking you for a ride. These people are fakes. These people love Bush.
“Again. And again. Vary the details. There are plenty. Somebody on the ‘list posted a strong list of McCain lies earlier today. Hammer it. Philosophize, as Nietzsche said, with a hammer.
“I don’t know about any of you, but I’m not waiting for any coordination. Get on with it!”
What the hell’s wrong indeed? The ends clearly justify the means, especially if we land jobs in the administration.
Kudos to Ezra Klein , the founder of JournoList on the suggestion that the 400 members of the list coordinate their pro-Obama message.
“Nope, no message coordination. I’m not even sure that would be legal. This is a discussion list, though, and I want it to retain that character,” he wrote.
Of course they did it anyway. Never ever trust anything the lefty media has to say.
Ode to John Kerry
Jul 25th
From the comments, JOMer’s ode to the senior senator from Massachusetts who is keeping his $7 million yacht in Rhode Island to avoid one of those pesky taxes he is so fond of passing.
Gems from JOM:
He thought “Screw that tax,” he could duck it
But once took his boat to Nantucket
And now she must pay
“What a fool!” said Teres’
“If only I’d dumped him that night in Pawtucket.”
Posted by: Extraneus
There was a pompous twit from Mass
who was known to be quite an ass
When it came to his taxes
he said he had axes
to grind with not getting a pass.
Posted by: Captain Hate
There once was a Senator from Nantucket
Who taxed yachters in Mass by the bucket
He anchored his in Rhode Island
To avoid duty filing
And to the Bean Stater’s Taxes he said “Phuket!”
Posted by: daddy
The Great Racism Smear
Jul 25th
The latest from Matt’s Meditations by Matt Holzmann
Today’s Daily Beast continues the racism meme so widespread in the media this week. It has morphed into a smear of all things Arizonan and all things conservative. The NAACP brouhaha is just icing on the cake for the Left’s smear of the Right.
Just this week, the band Rage Against the Machine has gotten back together to protest racism. The LA Times ran articles about Latinos fleeing Arizona for fear of racism. Illegal aliens are daring the government to deport them. Artists are agitating. Writers are writing. Hugo Chavez has weighed in. The governments of Mexico, El Salvador, and Guatemala want to file briefs on behalf of the Federal government’s suit against Arizona over SB 1070. And yet not a single instance of racism has been reported. With wall to wall reporters all over Arizona, not a peep.
The media has gone after the Tea Party with all guns blazing. Here are a couple of photos from tea parties I took. One in Santa Ana, California last year. The other in Lake Forest, California a few months ago. Orange County, the heart of darkness for liberals.
There is something very wrong with this picture. In bending over backwards on civil rights, our government; municipal, state, and federal, has created a grievance industry. Billions of dollars have been spent on dubious programs that push the envelope further and further so that more and more of us can say “it’s not my fault’. The internal dynamic and convoluted logic of the race baiters has twisted the idea of fairness and logic on its head.
And just as the left-wing conspiracy of the Journo-List is exposed, the shouts of racism have become the braying of a herd of asses. A website published photos of a number of the members of Journo-List. Almost all of them were white; from the same schools; the same social circles; members of the same organizations. Oleaginously homogenous. Groupthink and Groupspeak not often seen in this century outside of the various isms that plagued the planet in the 20th century.
Divide and conquer has been the tactic of empire and power since the age of the Romans. Today it is a useful tool for the American oligarchy. As they are looting the national treasury, they use the same tools that have been used through history to camouflage their actions, and most people, who don’t look too closely, fall for it.
Virtually every country in the world has reasonable control of their borders except ours. Mexico does. Honduras does. China does. Most do not allow large-scale immigration either. Most do not provide full social services for illegal or even legal immigrants. To live in Mexico it is explicitly stated that one must not become a burden on the state. I read the other day that New Zealand does not allow anyone over 55 to emigrate because of this as well. And yet this is the tinderbox being lit in this country. Ask yourself why this is so.
America has always been the land of opportunity. It has been a beacon for freedom. What has defined us is the rule of law. And if you work hard and follow the law the sky is the limit. America is the land of equality of opportunity, not equality of outcome.
Today, our own government for its own unstated purposes refuses to enforce our laws on immigration. Big business wants cheap labor and politicians want votes. For 200 years the social compact was followed by succeeding generations. Now, racism is being conflated to cross from the African-American community to the Latino-American community. It exists on the fringes, and frankly as the song from Avenue Q goes,”everyone’s a little bit racist“. But we are orders of magnitude farther down the path of equality than we were fifty or forty or thirty or even 20 years ago. Using this epithet is losing its meaning so long as we do not give in to the race baiters.
Let’s move beyond it. As Martin Luther King said ” I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character.” And let’s remember that it is character that counts.


